Why We Always Start With a Communications Assessment (Even When You Just Want Social Posts)

When we begin a partnership with a client, we always start with a comprehensive communications assessment. Sometimes, people say: “but we just want you to draft social media for us — why do you need to assess our communications tools?” or “but we just want you to do media monitoring for us — why do you need to analyze our messaging?” 

Well let us tell you. 

Evaluating your communications holistically is key not only to smart strategy, but it’s also key to smart fiscal decisions. Before deciding what to change or invest in, organizations should look at every aspect of their communications to determine what’s working — and what’s not. 

All the elements of communications work in tandem — there are no silos when it comes to comms — so if one thing is lacking, the others are impacted. If one part of a house’s foundation is sagging, the other parts start sagging in that direction, too. (We didn’t make the laws of gravity. We just live by them!) 

If you saw that the pipes in your home were leaking to your foundation, would you let it keep leaking and just paint over it? Nope. That is what a comprehensive communications assessment shows: what’s leaking, what’s creaking, and what’s strong. 

Just like you want an inspector to be when you buy a new home, communications assessments should be thorough. When we complete assessments, we look at: 

Messaging Analysis:

Assess your narrative, messaging, voice, and tone for clarity, consistency, and relevance to your audiences.

Why? TL;DR: Messaging is everything. You could be creating the cure for cancer, but if your messaging is off, people won’t connect. Can audiences quickly understand who you are, what you do, why it matters, and what makes you different? And just as importantly, is your messaging tailored to your target audience?  If not, you have a problem. An assessment identifies any opportunities to strengthen messaging that builds trust, drives engagement, and inspires action.

Digital Presence Audit:

Evaluate your website, digital channels, and other digital touchpoints for clarity, consistency, usability, and effectiveness.

Why? Social media used to be for the kids. Now, it’s the baseline for an online presence. What we look for depends on what your organizational goals are, but that’s the question: is your digital presence accomplishing your goals? Do you need to make information easier to find, set a strategic direction, or update your website? 

Leadership Voice Assessment:

Identify opportunities to strengthen how your leaders communicate their expertise, perspectives, and priorities.

Why? Because people connect with people. Even if your messaging and digital presence are strong (good for you!), having a face to an organization often enables people to put a face to the brand — for good (think: The Malala Fund) or for bad (think: Theranos and Elizabeth Holmes). So it’s crucial to know where your organizational leadership falls on the scale from Malala to Elizabeth Holmes. 

Our fingers are always crossed that it’s on the Malala end of the spectrum, but honestly, sometimes, it’s not. And that damage can outweigh anything else the organization’s communications can do. That, friends, is information you need to know.

Audience Research:

Explore audience needs, interests, perceptions, and communication preferences. 

Why? A lot of organizations haven’t actually talked to their audience before deciding what they need, want, or like to hear. Actual research replaces assumptions with a data-driven understanding of what your audiences value and respond to. This is a building block for all the other elements in an assessment. 

Landscape Analysis:

Understand how your organization compares with peers in positioning, messaging, and digital presence.

Why? Your organization is unique, but often, it’s hard to communicate why or how. A landscape analysis is an objective look at how your organization is perceived and positioned relative to peers. By looking from the outside in, we can identify places to differentiate your work — while also learning from what your peers in the space do well.  

Media & Press Audit:

Evaluate media coverage, visibility, and opportunities to strengthen your organization's presence.

Why? The old adage of “all press is good press” is definitely not true in 2026. Just ask Tesla. (Whoops, did we say that?!) Much like the leadership voice, bad press — or even press that doesn’t quite align with your organization's mission — can be an obstacle when it comes to successful communications. There’s a reason that crisis PR firms exist: and press coverage is it. 

Not only does a media & press audit reveal any weaknesses in how your organization is represented in external conversations, it also highlights opportunities for improvement. We can find relevant media outlets and opportunities that build your brand. 

Capabilities & tools audit:

Identify team strengths and opportunities to build communications skills through training, coaching, and practical resources.

Why? This one always gets folks! It doesn’t seem like a “communications” item, but it may be one of the most important. Bandwidth is one of the biggest challenges of mission-driven organizations. We take a look at how you’re using existing staff, resources, and technology so we can provide practical recommendations that align with your abilities.

Again, this is why an assessment should be holistic. If you come to us for a social media strategy, we could recommend an in-depth social media strategy that includes posting 3 times per day, 5 days a week. But if you don’t have 1) the staff to execute it or 2) the budget to hire a consultant, there’s no point in paying for that strategy, and you’ve wasted both your time and your resources.  

We’re not here to sell you services or get you to sign a contract. In our opinion, that’s a crappy way to do business. Of course, we’d like to partner together, but in a way that actually works for your organization. 

These assessments usually unearth things that organizations don’t know are a problem. Honestly, that’s the point. If your digital marketing is way out of alignment but you only invest time and effort into improving your thought leadership, you still won’t get where you want to go.

Next
Next

What Does the Data Say? Your Comms Strategy Is Only as Good as the Research Behind It.